R&L Logo R&L Logo
  • GENERAL
    • Browse by Subjects
    • New Releases
    • Coming Soon
    • Chases's Calendar
  • ACADEMIC
    • Textbooks
    • Browse by Course
    • Instructor's Copies
    • Monographs & Research
    • Reference
  • PROFESSIONAL
    • Education
    • Intelligence & Security
    • Library Services
    • Business & Leadership
    • Museum Studies
    • Music
    • Pastoral Resources
    • Psychotherapy
  • FREUD SET
Cover Image
Hardback
Paperback
eBook
share of facebook share on twitter
Add to GoodReads

Approaching the U.S. Constitution

Sacred Covenant or Plaything for Lawyers and Judges

Kerry L. Hunter

By reminding readers that early Supreme Court justices refused to reduce the Constitution to a mere legal document, Approaching the U.S. Constitution provides a definitive response to Reading Law by Antonin Scalia and Bryan Garner. Turning to the vision of Alexander Hamilton found in Federalists No. 78, Hunter argues that rather than seeing the judiciary as America’s legal guardian, Hamilton looked to independent individuals of integrity on the judiciary to be the nation’s collective conscience. For Hamilton, the judiciary’s authority over the legislature does not derive from positive law but is extra-legal by 'design' and is purely moral.

By emphasizing the
legal expertise of judges alone, individuals such as Justice Scalia mistakenly demand that judges exercise no human ethical judgment whatsoever. Yet the more this happens, the more the “rule of law” is replaced by the rule of lawyers. Legal sophistry becomes the primary currency wherewith society’s ethical and moral questions are resolved. Moreover, the alleged neutrality of legal analysis is deceptive with its claims of judicial modesty. It is not only undemocratic, it is dictatorial and highly elitist. Public debate over questions of fairness is replaced by an exclusive legalistic debate between lawyers over what is legal. The more Scalia and Garner realize their agenda, the more all appeals to what is moral will be effectively removed from political debate. 'Conservatives' lament the 'removing God from the classroom,' by 'liberals,' yet if the advocates of legalism get their way, God will be effectively removed from the polis altogether.

The answer to preserving both separation of powers and the American commitment to unalienable human rights is to view the Supreme Court in the same way early founders such as Hamilton did and in the way President Abraham Lincoln urged. The Court’s most important function in exercising the power of judicial review is to serve as the nation’s conscience just as it did in
Brown v. Board of Education.
  • Details
  • Details
  • Author
  • Author
  • TOC
  • TOC
  • Reviews
  • Reviews
Lexington Books
Pages: 174 • Trim: 6⅜ x 9¼
978-0-7391-9082-1 • Hardback • June 2014 • $120.00 • (£92.00)
978-0-7391-9721-9 • Paperback • April 2016 • $54.99 • (£42.00)
978-0-7391-9083-8 • eBook • June 2014 • $52.00 • (£40.00)
Subjects: Law / Constitutional, Law / Legal History, Political Science / Constitutions, Political Science / American Government / General
Kerry L. Hunter is full professor in the Department of Political Economy at the College of Idaho.
Chapter One: Approaching the United States Constitution: Sacred Covenant or Mere Plaything For Lawyers and Judges
Chapter Two: American Utopian Constitutionalism
Chapter Three: Hamilton’s Court as Conscience
Chapter Four: The Umpire Has No Clothes
Chapter Five: Toward Embracing Hamilton’s Ideal
America’s litigious excesses may be inhibiting rather than advancing the cause of justice, argues Kerry Hunter. In an inventive new approach, Hunter grapples with the central question of how we conceive of our Constitution, and who, by rights, may lay claim to its interpretation. Drawing on the case of New Zealand, where courts lack judicial review, and infusing a fresh view of Alexander Hamilton, Hunter rightly warns us that legal sophistry is not only no substitute for, but may be inimical to, American justice.
— Robert J. Spitzer, Distinguished Service Professor of Political Science, SUNY Cortland; author, "The Politics of Gun Control" and "Guns Across America: Reconciling Gun Rules and Rights"


Professor Hunter has written an impassioned, original, and timely challenge to the legal sophistry and constitutional obsessions that are undermining U.S. politics. His argument is informed by a comparative cross-national perspective and long study of American legal practices. The result is a heady, provocative ethical defense of democratic ideals against narrow legalism and its corrosive effects on our polity.
— Michael McCann, University of Washington


Approaching the U.S. Constitution

Sacred Covenant or Plaything for Lawyers and Judges

Cover Image
Hardback
Paperback
eBook
Summary
Summary
  • By reminding readers that early Supreme Court justices refused to reduce the Constitution to a mere legal document, Approaching the U.S. Constitution provides a definitive response to Reading Law by Antonin Scalia and Bryan Garner. Turning to the vision of Alexander Hamilton found in Federalists No. 78, Hunter argues that rather than seeing the judiciary as America’s legal guardian, Hamilton looked to independent individuals of integrity on the judiciary to be the nation’s collective conscience. For Hamilton, the judiciary’s authority over the legislature does not derive from positive law but is extra-legal by 'design' and is purely moral.

    By emphasizing the
    legal expertise of judges alone, individuals such as Justice Scalia mistakenly demand that judges exercise no human ethical judgment whatsoever. Yet the more this happens, the more the “rule of law” is replaced by the rule of lawyers. Legal sophistry becomes the primary currency wherewith society’s ethical and moral questions are resolved. Moreover, the alleged neutrality of legal analysis is deceptive with its claims of judicial modesty. It is not only undemocratic, it is dictatorial and highly elitist. Public debate over questions of fairness is replaced by an exclusive legalistic debate between lawyers over what is legal. The more Scalia and Garner realize their agenda, the more all appeals to what is moral will be effectively removed from political debate. 'Conservatives' lament the 'removing God from the classroom,' by 'liberals,' yet if the advocates of legalism get their way, God will be effectively removed from the polis altogether.

    The answer to preserving both separation of powers and the American commitment to unalienable human rights is to view the Supreme Court in the same way early founders such as Hamilton did and in the way President Abraham Lincoln urged. The Court’s most important function in exercising the power of judicial review is to serve as the nation’s conscience just as it did in
    Brown v. Board of Education.
Details
Details
  • Lexington Books
    Pages: 174 • Trim: 6⅜ x 9¼
    978-0-7391-9082-1 • Hardback • June 2014 • $120.00 • (£92.00)
    978-0-7391-9721-9 • Paperback • April 2016 • $54.99 • (£42.00)
    978-0-7391-9083-8 • eBook • June 2014 • $52.00 • (£40.00)
    Subjects: Law / Constitutional, Law / Legal History, Political Science / Constitutions, Political Science / American Government / General
Author
Author
  • Kerry L. Hunter is full professor in the Department of Political Economy at the College of Idaho.
Table of Contents
Table of Contents
  • Chapter One: Approaching the United States Constitution: Sacred Covenant or Mere Plaything For Lawyers and Judges
    Chapter Two: American Utopian Constitutionalism
    Chapter Three: Hamilton’s Court as Conscience
    Chapter Four: The Umpire Has No Clothes
    Chapter Five: Toward Embracing Hamilton’s Ideal
Reviews
Reviews
  • America’s litigious excesses may be inhibiting rather than advancing the cause of justice, argues Kerry Hunter. In an inventive new approach, Hunter grapples with the central question of how we conceive of our Constitution, and who, by rights, may lay claim to its interpretation. Drawing on the case of New Zealand, where courts lack judicial review, and infusing a fresh view of Alexander Hamilton, Hunter rightly warns us that legal sophistry is not only no substitute for, but may be inimical to, American justice.
    — Robert J. Spitzer, Distinguished Service Professor of Political Science, SUNY Cortland; author, "The Politics of Gun Control" and "Guns Across America: Reconciling Gun Rules and Rights"


    Professor Hunter has written an impassioned, original, and timely challenge to the legal sophistry and constitutional obsessions that are undermining U.S. politics. His argument is informed by a comparative cross-national perspective and long study of American legal practices. The result is a heady, provocative ethical defense of democratic ideals against narrow legalism and its corrosive effects on our polity.
    — Michael McCann, University of Washington


ALSO AVAILABLE

  • Cover image for the book The Right to Privacy in Texas: From Common Law Origins to 21st Century Protections
  • Cover image for the book Freedom of Expression in the Supreme Court: The Defining Cases
  • Cover image for the book Tried and Convicted: How Police, Prosecutors, and Judges Destroy Our Constitutional Rights
  • Cover image for the book The Dismissal of Gough Whitlam and the Australian Constitutional Crisis of 1975: When No One Knew the Rules
  • Cover image for the book The Biblical Roots of American Constitutionalism: From
  • Cover image for the book A Principled Constitution?: Four Skeptical Views
  • Cover image for the book The Concept of Ordered Liberty and the Common-Law Due-Process Tradition: Slaughterhouse Cases through Obergefell v. Hodges (1872–2015)
  • Cover image for the book Challenges to the American Founding: Slavery, Historicism, and Progressivism in the Nineteenth Century
  • Cover image for the book Justice Rehnquist, the Supreme Court, and the Bill of Rights
  • Cover image for the book Guardian of the Wall: Leo Pfeffer and the Religion Clauses of the First Amendment
  • Cover image for the book The Supreme Court, the Constitution, and William Rehnquist
  • Cover image for the book A Companion to the United States Constitution and Its Amendments, Fifth Edition
  • Cover image for the book America in Decline: How the Loss of Civic Virtue and Standards of Excellence Is Causing the End of Pax Americana
  • Cover image for the book Freedom of Speech in the Western World: Comparison and Critique
  • Cover image for the book How to Read the Constitution: Originalism, Constitutional Interpretation, and Judicial Power
  • Cover image for the book The Naked Australian Constitution: Interpretations, Inadequacies, and Implications
  • Cover image for the book Storm Over the Constitution
  • Cover image for the book The Tenth Amendment and State Sovereignty: Constitutional History and Contemporary Issues
  • Cover image for the book The Unwritten Brazilian Constitution: Human Rights in the Supremo Tribunal Federal
  • Cover image for the book Constitutional Law and Federations
  • Cover image for the book The Presidential Republic: Executive Representation and Deliberative Democracy
  • Cover image for the book The Religion Clauses of the First Amendment: Guarantees of States' Rights?
  • Cover image for the book Summaries of Leading Cases on the Constitution, 14th Edition
  • Cover image for the book Australia’s American Constitution and the Dismissal: How English Legal Science Marred the Founders’ Vision
  • Cover image for the book The Writing and Ratification of the U.S. Constitution: Practical Virtue in Action
  • Cover image for the book America’s Two Constitutions: A Study of the Treatment of Dissenters in Time of War
  • Cover image for the book Physician-Assisted Suicide: The Anatomy of a Constitutional Law Issue
  • Cover image for the book American Constitutionalism, Marriage, and the Family: Obergefell v. Hodges and U.S. v. Windsor in Context
  • Cover image for the book Impartial Justice: The Real Supreme Court Cases that Define the Constitutional Right to a Neutral and Detached Decisionmaker
  • Cover image for the book Clashing Worldviews in the U.S. Supreme Court: Rehnquist vs. Blackmun
  • Cover image for the book Reason and Republicanism: Thomas Jefferson's Legacy of Liberty
  • Cover image for the book Perfecting the Constitution: The Case for the Article V Amendment Process
  • Cover image for the book The U.S. Supreme Court and New Federalism: From the Rehnquist to the Roberts Court
  • Cover image for the book Select Legal Topics, Volume 2
  • Cover image for the book Ranters Run Amok: And Other Adventures in the History of the Law
  • Cover image for the book The Right to Privacy in Texas: From Common Law Origins to 21st Century Protections
  • Cover image for the book Freedom of Expression in the Supreme Court: The Defining Cases
  • Cover image for the book Tried and Convicted: How Police, Prosecutors, and Judges Destroy Our Constitutional Rights
  • Cover image for the book The Dismissal of Gough Whitlam and the Australian Constitutional Crisis of 1975: When No One Knew the Rules
  • Cover image for the book The Biblical Roots of American Constitutionalism: From
  • Cover image for the book A Principled Constitution?: Four Skeptical Views
  • Cover image for the book The Concept of Ordered Liberty and the Common-Law Due-Process Tradition: Slaughterhouse Cases through Obergefell v. Hodges (1872–2015)
  • Cover image for the book Challenges to the American Founding: Slavery, Historicism, and Progressivism in the Nineteenth Century
  • Cover image for the book Justice Rehnquist, the Supreme Court, and the Bill of Rights
  • Cover image for the book Guardian of the Wall: Leo Pfeffer and the Religion Clauses of the First Amendment
  • Cover image for the book The Supreme Court, the Constitution, and William Rehnquist
  • Cover image for the book A Companion to the United States Constitution and Its Amendments, Fifth Edition
  • Cover image for the book America in Decline: How the Loss of Civic Virtue and Standards of Excellence Is Causing the End of Pax Americana
  • Cover image for the book Freedom of Speech in the Western World: Comparison and Critique
  • Cover image for the book How to Read the Constitution: Originalism, Constitutional Interpretation, and Judicial Power
  • Cover image for the book The Naked Australian Constitution: Interpretations, Inadequacies, and Implications
  • Cover image for the book Storm Over the Constitution
  • Cover image for the book The Tenth Amendment and State Sovereignty: Constitutional History and Contemporary Issues
  • Cover image for the book The Unwritten Brazilian Constitution: Human Rights in the Supremo Tribunal Federal
  • Cover image for the book Constitutional Law and Federations
  • Cover image for the book The Presidential Republic: Executive Representation and Deliberative Democracy
  • Cover image for the book The Religion Clauses of the First Amendment: Guarantees of States' Rights?
  • Cover image for the book Summaries of Leading Cases on the Constitution, 14th Edition
  • Cover image for the book Australia’s American Constitution and the Dismissal: How English Legal Science Marred the Founders’ Vision
  • Cover image for the book The Writing and Ratification of the U.S. Constitution: Practical Virtue in Action
  • Cover image for the book America’s Two Constitutions: A Study of the Treatment of Dissenters in Time of War
  • Cover image for the book Physician-Assisted Suicide: The Anatomy of a Constitutional Law Issue
  • Cover image for the book American Constitutionalism, Marriage, and the Family: Obergefell v. Hodges and U.S. v. Windsor in Context
  • Cover image for the book Impartial Justice: The Real Supreme Court Cases that Define the Constitutional Right to a Neutral and Detached Decisionmaker
  • Cover image for the book Clashing Worldviews in the U.S. Supreme Court: Rehnquist vs. Blackmun
  • Cover image for the book Reason and Republicanism: Thomas Jefferson's Legacy of Liberty
  • Cover image for the book Perfecting the Constitution: The Case for the Article V Amendment Process
  • Cover image for the book The U.S. Supreme Court and New Federalism: From the Rehnquist to the Roberts Court
  • Cover image for the book Select Legal Topics, Volume 2
  • Cover image for the book Ranters Run Amok: And Other Adventures in the History of the Law
facebook icon twitter icon instagram icon linked in icon NEWSLETTERS
ABOUT US
  • Mission Statement
  • Employment
  • Privacy
  • Accessibility Statement
CONTACT
  • Company Directory
  • Publicity and Media Queries
  • Rights and Permissions
  • Textbook Resource Center
AUTHOR RESOURCES
  • Royalty Contact
  • Production Guidelines
  • Manuscript Submissions
ORDERING INFORMATION
  • Rowman & Littlefield
  • National Book Network
  • Ingram Publisher Services UK
  • Special Sales
  • International Sales
  • eBook Partners
  • Digital Catalogs
IMPRINTS
  • Rowman & Littlefield
  • Lexington Books
  • Hamilton Books
  • Applause Books
  • Amadeus Press
  • Backbeat Books
  • Bernan
  • Hal Leonard Books
  • Limelight Editions
  • Co-Publishing Partners
  • Globe Pequot
  • Down East Books
  • Falcon Guides
  • Gooseberry Patch
  • Lyons Press
  • Muddy Boots
  • Pineapple Press
  • TwoDot Books
  • Stackpole Books
PARTNERS
  • American Alliance of Museums
  • American Association for State and Local History
  • Brookings Institution Press
  • Center for Strategic & International Studies
  • Council on Foreign Relations
  • Fairleigh Dickinson University Press
  • Fortress Press
  • The Foundation for Critical Thinking
  • Lehigh University Press
  • United States Holocaust Memorial Museum
  • Other Partners...