Open Compositionality

Toward a New Methodology of Language

Eduardo García-Ramírez

Open Compositionality: Towards a New Methodology of Language argues that natural languages, like English and Spanish, are not only systems of representation useful for communication but also highly interactive cognitive capacities allowing humans to engage in complex forms of cognition. This view goes against the orthodox approach within philosophy of language, which considers natural languages to be specialized systems consisting of only linguistic elements and functioning in a closed compositional manner, allowing for fully formal, algebraic descriptions. Eduardo García-Ramírez rejects the longstanding principle of compositionality, according to which the meaning of any complex expression is fully determined by its parts and the way they are combined, and he substitutes it with an alternative, open, and interactive one. This novel view of the nature of language better accounts for the empirical evidence. García Ramírez develops an account of open compositionality, accompanied by the cognition-first methodology, in which natural languages are conceived as supermodular cognitive capacities that allow for interaction among multiple distinct areas of human cognition. The explanatory success of this original proposal and its accompanying methodology are tested by the author’s account of three enduring philosophical problems: substitution failure, empty names, and the nature of moral discourse.

Lexington Books

Pages: 252 • Trim: 6½ x 9

978-1-4985-6272-0 • Hardback • June 2019 • $117.00 • (£90.00)

978-1-4985-6273-7 • eBook • June 2019 • $111.00 • (£85.00)

Subjects: Philosophy / Language, Language Arts & Disciplines / Linguistics / Psycholinguistics

Open Compositionality

Toward a New Methodology of Language

Hardback

eBook

Summary

Open Compositionality: Towards a New Methodology of Language argues that natural languages, like English and Spanish, are not only systems of representation useful for communication but also highly interactive cognitive capacities allowing humans to engage in complex forms of cognition. This view goes against the orthodox approach within philosophy of language, which considers natural languages to be specialized systems consisting of only linguistic elements and functioning in a closed compositional manner, allowing for fully formal, algebraic descriptions. Eduardo García-Ramírez rejects the longstanding principle of compositionality, according to which the meaning of any complex expression is fully determined by its parts and the way they are combined, and he substitutes it with an alternative, open, and interactive one. This novel view of the nature of language better accounts for the empirical evidence. García Ramírez develops an account of open compositionality, accompanied by the cognition-first methodology, in which natural languages are conceived as supermodular cognitive capacities that allow for interaction among multiple distinct areas of human cognition. The explanatory success of this original proposal and its accompanying methodology are tested by the author’s account of three enduring philosophical problems: substitution failure, empty names, and the nature of moral discourse.

Details

Lexington Books

Pages: 252 • Trim: 6½ x 9

978-1-4985-6272-0 • Hardback • June 2019 • $117.00 • (£90.00)

978-1-4985-6273-7 • eBook • June 2019 • $111.00 • (£85.00)

Subjects: Philosophy / Language, Language Arts & Disciplines / Linguistics / Psycholinguistics

Author

Eduardo García Ramírez is research fellow at the Institute for Philosophical Research of the National Autonomous University of Mexico.

Table of Contents

Preface

1. Two Views of Language

2. The Closed View and Strong Compositionality

3. The Failure of Strong Compositionality

4. Open Compositionality and the Cognition First Methodology

5. Lexical Processing Architecture and Substitution Failure

6. Decoupled Representations and Empty Names

7. Moral Discourse, Moral Cognition and the Language Analogy

Bibliography

Reviews

This book offers a completely new look at the traditional Principle of Compositionality and its power to account for the meaning of linguistic expressions. García Ramírez lucidly argues against what he calls 'Closed Compositionality,' i.e., the idea that the meaning of complex expressions in a given language is fully determined on the basis of its lexicon and syntactic/semantic axioms. From the author’s perspective, the interpretation of those expressions strongly depends on the different kinds of cognitive processes underlying their use. After a careful evaluation of recent discoveries in psycholinguistics and neurosciences, García Ramírez proposes an original alternative thesis, Open Compositionality, according to which complex linguistic expressions can only be adequately interpreted on grounds of a multifaceted decision-making procedure. Open Compositionality convincingly deploys the significant advantages for the study of natural language carried by this extraordinary methodological turn. It should be read by anyone interested in getting a clearer idea of how we are able to communicate with one another through language use.
— Eleonora Orlando, University of Buenos Aires

Open Compositionality

Toward a New Methodology of Language

Eduardo García-Ramírez

Open Compositionality

Toward a New Methodology of Language

ALSO AVAILABLE