Fascinating, well written, and timely. This is outstanding, original media history. Why do so many conservatives find liberal bias in the mainstream media when the journalists think they’re just doing their truth-seeking, democracy-sustaining job? Rich Shumate finds clues in standard social psychological principles that apply to any politically impassioned groups, but he enriches this with a detailed and eye-opening account of how conservative groups jousted with the media in the Goldwater presidential bid of 1960-64.
— Michael Schudson, Columbia University
Is there liberal media bias? This book artfully sidesteps this popular—if unproductive and ultimately unanswerable—question, drawing much-needed attention to the role of media perception in the development of modern conservative identity in the United States. Shumate synthesizes the work of leading social psychology and cultural studies theorists, offering a useful framework for interrogating the conservative news reading strategies that result in perceptions of bias. This book is an important contribution to conservative news studies and astutely captures the growing disconnect between conservative audiences and mainstream journalists in the early 1960s.
— A.J. Bauer, University of Alabama
This book provides a theoretically sophisticated, historically informed account of the claims of "liberal bias" during the early 1960s. The book is creative, insightful, and provides valuable context for current charges of "liberal bias," helping us see both where they come from and why they are unlikely to go away any time soon. It should be of interest to communications scholars, political scientists, historians, and ordinary citizens.
— Beth Rosenson, University of Florida
In Barry Goldwater, Distrust in Media, and Conservative Identity, Rich Shumate skillfully dissects the origins of the conservative belief in a biased, liberal press. By studying the political turmoil of the early sixties, particularly the coverage of the 1964 presidential campaign of Barry Goldwater, he delivers an engaging and comprehensive history of conservative antipathy to the media. Read it to understand not only the source of this belief system, but also to better comprehend our current, polarized media environment.
— Robert Mann, Author of Daisy Petals and Mushroom Clouds: LBJ, Barry Goldwater, and the Spot that Changed American Politics
Despite a lack of evidence, the perception of liberal bias in the news media has persisted since the middle of the 20th Century. In Barry Goldwater, Distrust in Media, and Conservative Identity, Rich Shumate traces the roots of this lingering perception to the period from 1960 to 1964. He argues that mainstream media’s elite status, adversarial approach, and framing of politics as conflict – rather than an explicit liberal bias in content – led members of an emerging conservative movement to decode news coverage as hostile to their social identity. The result is a book that not only illuminates an important moment in the history of media and politics in the United States, but also provides a lens through which to better understand our contemporary moment.
— Michael X. Delli Carpini, University of Pennsylvania